What if I Preach a Bad Sermon?

By Brian Croft

Every preacher has preached a bad sermon.  If you think you haven’t, then you’ve probably preached a bunch of bad sermons!

It will happen to all of us.  Sometimes it won’t just be bad, but a disaster!  When a sermon doesn’t go well, most of us get very discouraged — and if the despair is great enough, we might question whether we should keep preaching at all.

But I bet no one can top the disaster of John Newton’s first sermon, as he described it to a friend in a letter he wrote the next day:

I set off tolerably well, though with no small fear and trembling …. Before I had spoken 10 minutes I was stopped like Hannibal upon the Alps. My ideas forsook me; darkness and confusion filled up their place. I stood on a precipice and could not advance a step forward. I stared at the people and they at me. Not a word more could I speak but was forced to come down and leave the people, some smiling, some weeping. My pride and self-sufficiency were solely mortified.

Imagine if John Newton, one of the most celebrated pastors, preachers, hymn composers, and letter writers in the past 4oo years, took that one bad sermon as proof that he should not preach? How tragic would that have been? Most of our first sermons were bad, and most pastors “lay eggs,” even after years of preaching.  But take heart! Our Sovereign God doesn’t use perfect preachers and sermons, but imperfect, broken, jars of clay to proclaim His perfect word — and the Spirit uniquely works through this design.

So, if you preached a bad sermon recently, welcome to the club! God’s mercies are new every morning — and that includes your preaching ministry. Embrace your brokenness and need to grow. Trust that you have not ruined your church because of one bad sermon (or several for that matter).  Allow the grace of God in Christ to pick you back up and help you saddle up for next Sunday. God used John Newton in amazing ways, despite this terrible experience ,and he will continue to use you in your ministry.

If you are just testing your gifts to preach, embrace any opportunity you get to preach and listen to feedback from others. Even if it is hard to hear, God will use that to help you grow.

Newton didn’t allow a really bad sermon to cause him to give up.  Nor should you.

This post originally appeared on Practical Shepherding’s blog.,

Published May 27, 2020

P.S. Get our best content in your inbox

We send one email per month full of articles from a variety of Replanting voices.

Brian Croft

Brian Croft is founder and executive director of Practical Shepherding. He is also the senior fellow for the Mathena Center for Church Revitalization at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary and has written over a dozen books on pastoral ministry. He is married to Cara and they have four children. You can follow him @pastorcroft.